Skip to Main content
ORDER ONLINE NOW! Same low prices - no hidden fees, no extra charges!
  • Goodfellas Pizza

GoodFellas Pizzeria

745 West Market Street, Niagara Falls, NY
‌
‌

Featured Items

  • 1/2 Tray Pizza and 20 Wings

    Classic cheese pizza and one free topping plus 20 wings. Add additional toppings for extra.
    MOST POPULAR
    $38.98
  • Slice - Pepperoni

    One square slice from our fresh pepperoni and cheese pizza, warmed in the oven.
    $2.50
  • Personal Pie

    Personal pie pizza cut into 4 pieces. One free topping is included.
    $9.98

Food

House Specials

  • 1/2 Tray Pizza and 20 Wings

    Classic cheese pizza and one free topping plus 20 wings. Add additional toppings for extra.
    MOST POPULAR
    $38.98
  • Full Tray Pizza and 30 Wings

    Classic cheese pizza and one free topping plus 30 wings. Add additional toppings for extra.
    $65.98
  • Full Tray Pizza and 50 Wings

    Classic cheese pizza and one free topping plus 50 wings. Add additional toppings for extra.
    $77.98

Pizzas

  • Tray Pizza

    Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
    $29.98
  • 1/2 Tray Pizza

    Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
    $15.98
  • Large Pie

    Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
    $18.98
  • Medium Pie

    Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
    $15.98
  • Slice - Pepperoni

    One square slice from our fresh pepperoni and cheese pizza, warmed in the oven.
    $2.50
  • Slice - Cheese

    One square slice from our fresh cheese pizza, warmed in the oven.
    $2.00
  • Personal Pie

    Personal pie pizza cut into 4 pieces. One free topping is included.
    $9.98

Specialty Pizzas

  • Medium White Pizza

    $18.98
  • Large White Pizza

    $21.98
  • Half Tray White Pizza

    $17.98
  • Full tray White Pizza

    $27.98
  • Medium Chicken Finger Pizza

    $18.98
  • Large Chicken Finger Pizza

    Your choice of tomato, blue cheese, ranch or white base; topped with chicken fingers tossed in your choice of sauce.
    $21.98
  • Half Tray - Chicken Finger Pizza

    Your choice of tomato, blue cheese, ranch or white base; topped with chicken fingers tossed in your choice of sauce.
    $20.98
  • Full Tray - Chicken Finger Pizza

    Your choice of tomato, blue cheese, ranch or white base; topped with chicken fingers tossed in your choice of sauce.
    $30.98
  • Medium Steak Pizza

    $18.98
  • Large Steak Pizza

    $21.98
  • Half Tray Steak Pizza

    $20.98
  • Full Tray Steak Pizza

    $30.98
  • Gluten Free Pie

    $12.98
  • Cauliflower Crust

    $11.98
  • Half Tray BBQ Chicken

    $18.98
  • Full Tray BBQ Chicken

    $33.98

Wings/Fingers

  • 10 Boneless Wings

    Includes one 2 oz. cup of blue cheese.
    $11.98
  • 10 Wings

    Includes one 2 oz. cup of blue cheese.
    $14.98
  • 20 Wings

    Includes two 2 oz. cups of blue cheese.
    $26.98
  • 30 Wings

    Includes three (3) 2 oz. cups of blue cheese.
    $40.98
  • 50 Wings

    Includes 4 (four) 2 oz. cups of blue cheese.
    $65.98
  • 4 Fingers

    Includes one 2 oz. cup of blue cheese.
    $11.98
  • 8 Fingers

    Includes two 2 oz. cups of blue cheese
    $23.98
  • 12 Fingers

    Includes three (3) 2 oz. cups of blue cheese.
    $33.98
  • Extra Blue Cheese

    $1.50

Old Fashioned Pizzas

  • Full Tray - Old Fashioned Pizza

    A full tray made with a Pizza sauce base and topped with Parmesan cheese and sprinkled with oregano.
    $26.98
  • Half Tray - Old Fashioned Pizza

    1/2 tray made with a Pizza sauce base and topped with Parmesan cheese and sprinkled with oregano.
    $14.98
  • Large - Old Fashioned Pizza

    Large pie made with a pizza sauce base and topped with Parmesan cheese and sprinkled with oregano.
    $18.98
  • Medium - Old Fashioned Pizza

    Medium pie pizza with a Pizza sauce base topped with Parmesan cheese and sprinkled with oregano.
    $15.98

Finger Foods

  • Pizza Logs (5)

    Golden, crispy pizza dough rolled and stuffed with savory pizza sauce, melted mozzarella cheese, and pepperoni. Fried to perfection and served with a side of warm marinara sauce for dipping.
    $9.98
  • Jalapeño Poppers (8)

    Jalapeño peppers stuffed with melted cheese, coated in a breading, and fried. Served with a side of ranch
    $7.98
  • Mozzarella Sticks (5)

    Golden, crispy breaded mozzarella sticks fried to perfection with a warm, gooey cheese center. Served with a side of marinara sauce for dipping.
    $8.98
  • Fried Ravioli (12)

    Cheese-filled ravioli coated in a crispy, seasoned breading and fried until golden brown. Served with a side of marinara sauce for dipping.
    $8.98
  • Garlic Bread with Cheese

    Freshly baked bread, brushed with buttery garlic seasoning and topped with melted mozzarella cheese.
    $6.98
  • Small Fry

    $4.98
  • Large Fry

    $5.98
  • Small Poutine

    $6.98
  • Large Poutine

    $7.98
  • Onion Rings

    $5.98
  • 3 Fingers W/ Fries

    3 chicken fingers served with french fries and blue cheese.
    $10.98
  • Small Fry w/ Mozz Cheese

    Small order of fries with melted mozzarella cheese
    $5.98
  • Lg Fry w/ Mozz Cheese

    Large order of fries with melted mozzarella cheese
    $6.98

Subs

  • Small - Steak and Cheese Sub

    Our most popular sub! Steak and cheese with your choice of toppings, mayo and/or oil, on a sub roll.
    $10.98
  • Large - Steak and Cheese Sub

    Our most popular sub! Steak and cheese with your choice of toppings, mayo and/or oil, on a sub roll.
    MOST POPULAR!
    $12.98
  • Small - Chicken Finger Sub

    $10.98
  • Large - Chicken Finger Sub

    $12.98
  • Small - Sausage and Cheese Sub

    $10.98
  • Large - Sausage and Cheese Sub

    $12.98
  • Small - Ham and Cheese Sub

    $10.98
  • Large - Ham and Cheese Sub

    $12.98
  • Small - Assorted with Cheese Sub

    Ham, salami and capocolla on a sub roll.
    $10.98
  • Large - Assorted with Cheese Sub

    Ham, salami and capocolla on a sub roll.
    $12.98
  • Small - Turkey and Cheese Sub

    $10.98
  • Large - Turkey and Cheese Sub

    $12.98
  • Small - Salami and Cheese Sub

    $10.98
  • Large - Salami and Cheese Sub

    $12.98
  • Small - Capocollo and Cheese Sub

    $10.98
  • Large - Capocollo and Cheese Sub

    $12.98
  • Small - Pizza Sub

    Pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese and pepperoni on a sub roll.
    $10.98
  • Large - Pizza Sub

    Pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese and pepperoni on a sub roll.
    $12.98
  • Small - BLT Sub

    Bacon, lettuce and tomato on a sub roll.
    $10.98
  • Large - BLT Sub

    Bacon, lettuce and tomato on a sub roll.
    $12.98
  • Small - Cheeseburger Sub

    $10.98
  • Large - Cheeseburger Sub

    $12.98

Specialty Subs

  • Small - Stinger Sub

    Our classic steak sub but make it better! Steak and chicken fingers made with your choice of sauce, topped with cheese, lettuce and oil or mayo.
    $11.98
  • Large - Stinger Sub

    Our classic steak sub but make it better! Steak and chicken fingers made with your choice of sauce, topped with cheese, lettuce and oil or mayo.
    STAFF FAVORITE!
    $13.98
  • Small - Royal Sub

    $11.98
  • Large - Royal Sub

    $13.98
  • Small - Chicken Parmigiana Sub

    Breaded chicken topped with marinara sauce and melted cheese on a sub roll.
    $11.98
  • Large - Chicken Parmigiana Sub

    Breaded chicken topped with marinara sauce and melted cheese on a sub roll.
    $13.98
  • Small - Meatball Sub

    Breaded chicken topped with marinara sauce and melted cheese.
    $11.98
  • Large - Meatball Sub

    Meatballs topped with melted cheese and marinara sauce on a sub roll.
    $13.98

Burritos

  • Steak Burrito

    $10.98
  • Chicken Burrito

    $9.98
  • Stinger Burrito

    $12.98

Salads

  • Dinner Salad

    $5.25
  • Chef Salad

    $9.98
  • Julienne Salad

    $12.98
  • Grilled Chicken Salad

    $13.98
  • Chicken Finger Salad

    $13.98
  • Antipasto

    $13.98
  • Chicken Taco Bowl Salad

    $13.50
  • Steak Taco Bowl Salad

    $14.98

Dinners

  • Pasta Dinner with Meatballs

    Your choice of spaghetti or penne pasta, pasta sauce and meatballs. Served with bread and butter.
    $12.98
  • Fish Fry

    Fried haddock fish, French fries, mac salad, coleslaw, bread, and tartar sauce
    OUT OF STOCK
    $14.98

Sandwiches & Burgers

  • 1/2 lb Hamburger w/ Fries

    $12.98
  • Grilled Chicken Sandwich w/ Fries

    $12.98

Dottie's Chicken Soup (Oct-May)

  • Pint of Soup

    $5.98
  • Quart of Soup

    $11.98

Extra/Sides

  • Side - Blue Cheese

    2 oz. cup
    $1.50
  • Side - Sauce

    $1.50
  • Side - Gravy

    $1.75
  • Side - Sour Cream

    $1.00
  • Side - Salsa

    $1.25
  • Side - Honey Garlic

    $1.50
  • Side - Ranch

    $1.50
  • Side - BBQ Sauce

    $1.50
  • Side - Hot Sauce

    $1.50
  • Side - Medium Sauce

    $1.50
  • Side - Ketchup

    $0.75

Desserts

  • Fried Dough Bites (12)

    Warm, golden fried dough bites topped with powdered sugar and cinnamon.
    MUST TRY
    $7.98

Drinks

  • Coca-Cola Cherry, 2 Liters

    Delicious combination of Coca-Cola and cherry flavor
    $3.75
  • Coca-Cola, 2 Liters

    Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love
    $3.75
  • Diet Coke, 2 Liters

    Take a Diet Coke break with this refreshing, no-calorie soft drink
    $3.75
  • Canada Dry Ginger Ale, 2 Liters

    $3.75
  • Sprite, 2 Liters

    Classic, cool, crisp lemon-lime flavored taste that's caffeine free
    $3.75
  • Barq's Root Beer, 2 Liters

    $3.75
  • Crystal Beach Loganberry, 2 Liters

    $3.75
  • Fanta Orange, 2 Liters

    Liberate your every day with fizzy and refreshing fruit-flavored Fanta soda pop
    $3.75
  • Gold Peak Sweet Tea, 20oz

    Gold Peak is real brewed tea made from tea leaves picked for peak taste. Gold Peak Real Brewed Tea has a variety of flavors that pair marvelously with any family occasion, from backyard get-togethers, to holiday traditions, to weekend getaways. Real Brewed. Real Tea. Real Good.
    $2.98
  • Gold Peak Unsweetened Tea

    $2.98
  • Minute Maid Lemonade, 20oz

    There’s always goodness to be found at the end of a Minute Maid rainbow.
    $2.89
  • Fanta Orange, 20oz

    Liberate your every day with fizzy and refreshing fruit-flavored Fanta soda pop
    $2.89
  • Dasani Water, 20oz

    Enhanced with minerals for a crisp, clean and fresh taste
    $2.50
  • Minute Maid Fruit Punch, 20oz

    There’s always goodness to be found at the end of a Minute Maid rainbow.
    $2.89
  • Barq's Root Beer, 20oz

    $2.89
  • Coca-Cola, 20oz

    Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love
    $2.89
  • Diet Coke, 20oz

    Take a Diet Coke break with this refreshing, no-calorie soft drink
    $2.89
  • Canada Dry Ginger Ale, 20oz

    $2.89
  • Sprite, 20oz

    Classic, cool, crisp lemon-lime flavored taste that's caffeine free
    $2.89
  • Coca-Cola Zero Sugar, 20oz

    Enjoy the great taste of Coca-Cola with zero sugar, zero calories
    $2.89
  • Coca-Cola Cherry, 20oz

    $2.89

Lunch Specials

Everyday House Specials

  • Personal Pizza & Pop Lunch Special

    1 personal pie pizza (4 slices) and 1 20 oz. soda
    $11.95
  • 5 Wing & 2 Slice Lunch Special

    5 Chicken Wings and 2 Slices (cheese or cheese and pepperoni)
    $11.95
If you use a credit card, this establishment will charge an additional 3.00% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what this establishment pays in fees.

Medium - Old Fashioned Pizza

$15.98

Medium pie pizza with a Pizza sauce base topped with Parmesan cheese and sprinkled with oregano.

Customize your item

HALF Toppings

Optional

Bake and finishing requests

Optional

Pizza RH side

Optional

Pizza LH side

Optional
Request advisory
Please notify us of any allergies here.
1

Goodfellas Pizza Location and Hours

(716) 285-8448
745 West Market Street, Niagara Falls, NY 14301
Open now • Closes at 11PM
View menu
Facebook logoYelp logoTripadvisor logo
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement